Vantage City Case Files · Unit 3 boss level

Case 03: The Saltmarsh Clinic Night Shift

Vantage City’s Saltmarsh Clinic called at 7 a.m. Overnight, the patient portal slowed to a crawl, a contractor account logged in at 2 a.m., and the switch by the waiting room logged thousands of new devices. The clinic stores patient records, so this is sensitive. You have four pieces of evidence. Work through ten questions, then write up three findings, citing the exact line, to close the case.

10 questions · Analyze 2Mitigate 4Detect 4 About 20 min

The evidence

Evidence 1 Wireless access point configuration
ap-lobby-01: running configuration
ssid              SaltmarshClinic-Staff
security          wep
beacon-broadcast  enable
tx-power          max      # signal reaches the parking lot
mac-filter        disable
auth              shared-password
Evidence 2 Network firewall rules
edge-fw: inbound rules (checked in order, first match wins)
Rule numberActionSourceDestinationDirectionPort numberProtocol
1AllowALL10.0.1.20Inbound443HTTPS
2Deny198.51.100.0/2410.0.1.20Inbound443HTTPS
3AllowALL10.0.1.30Inbound3389RDP
4DenyALLALLInboundALLALL

10.0.1.20 is the patient portal server; 10.0.1.30 is the server the IT contractor uses. 198.51.100.0/24 is a known malicious range. HTTPS: Hypertext Transfer Protocol Secure. RDP: remote desktop protocol, used to control a computer remotely.

Evidence 3 Switch output
sw-front-02# show mac address-table count
Fa0/2   (reception PC)       1 dynamic address
Fa0/5   (exam room printer)  1 dynamic address
Fa0/7   (waiting room wall port)  8,189 dynamic addresses
Total in use: 8,191 of 8,192   <- table nearly full
Evidence 4 Firewall log
edge-fw log, 02:00 to 02:20
02:03  192.0.2.10    -> 10.0.1.20:443   ALLOW  rule 1   portal page load
02:06  198.51.100.23 -> 10.0.1.20:443   ALLOW  rule 1   portal login form
02:08  192.0.2.77    -> 10.0.1.30:3389  ALLOW  rule 3   238 failed logins in 90 s
02:10  192.0.2.77    -> 10.0.1.30:3389  ALLOW  rule 3   login SUCCESS: contractor
02:14  10.0.1.30     -> 203.0.113.66:443 ALLOW out     outbound connection

203.0.113.0/24 is on the clinic’s list of known malicious addresses.

The questions

  1. Analyze E1 Choose one

    1. Which setting in Evidence 1 is the biggest weakness for keeping intercepted wireless frames unreadable?

    Which setting in Evidence 1 is the biggest weakness for keeping intercepted wireless frames unreadable?
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Wired Equivalent Privacy (WEP) has known vulnerabilities and is insecure, so captured frames can be read. Encryption is what protects intercepted frames; Wi-Fi Protected Access 3 (WPA3) is currently the strongest. CED 3.2.B.3

  2. Mitigate E1 Select all that apply

    2. Select every change that would bring the access point in Evidence 1 in line with good wireless security.

    Select every change that would bring the access point in Evidence 1 in line with good wireless security.
    Show answer

    Answer: B, C, D, F. WPA3, disabled beacons, a signal limited to the building and MAC filtering with authentication all match 3.2.B. A longer network name adds no protection, and a maximum signal helps war drivers in the parking lot. In real networks, a hidden network name and MAC filtering are only small extras (names can be discovered and MAC addresses copied); WPA3 and per-user authentication do the real work. CED 3.2.B.1, 3.2.B.2, 3.2.B.3, 3.2.B.4

  3. Analyze E2E4 Choose one

    3. At 02:06 a request from 198.51.100.23 reached the portal, even though rule 2 denies that range. Why?

    At 02:06 a request from 198.51.100.23 reached the portal, even though rule 2 denies that range. Why?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Access control list rules are checked in order and the first match is executed. The broad allow rule sits above the specific deny rule. CED 3.4.B.2

  4. Mitigate E2 Choose one

    4. Which change fixes the problem from question 3 without blocking legitimate patients?

    Which change fixes the problem from question 3 without blocking legitimate patients?
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Specific rules go before broad ones. With the deny for the malicious range first, its traffic is blocked and everyone else still matches rule 1. Deleting rule 1 or moving the default deny up would block patients too. CED 3.4.D.3

  5. Detect E4 Choose one

    5. What do the 02:08 and 02:10 log lines show?

    What do the 02:08 and 02:10 log lines show?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Hundreds of failed logins in a short time, at an unusual hour, from an unknown address, then a success: the signs of an online password attack, and it worked. CED 1.2.A.2

  6. Mitigate E2E4 Select all that apply

    6. Select the two changes that best reduce the risk from rule 3.

    Select the two changes that best reduce the risk from rule 3.
    Show answer

    Answer: C, D. Restricting the source address shrinks who can even try, and MFA means a guessed password alone is not enough. Moving rule 3 below the default deny would block the contractor completely. CED 3.4.D.2, 1.2.C.3

  7. Detect E3 Choose one

    7. What does Evidence 3 indicate on port Fa0/7?

    What does Evidence 3 indicate on port Fa0/7?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Thousands of MAC addresses on one port and a nearly full table are the signature of MAC flooding. Once the table overflows, the switch can be forced into broadcast mode, so the adversary can collect frames meant for other devices (eavesdropping). CED 3.5.E.4, 3.1.A.2

  8. Mitigate E3 Choose one

    8. Which control most directly stops the attack in Evidence 3 from happening again?

    Which control most directly stops the attack in Evidence 3 from happening again?
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Port security limits the number of MAC addresses on a switch port, which prevents MAC flooding. A wall port in a public waiting room is exposed, so it could also be disabled when not needed. CED 3.3.B.4

  9. Detect E4 Select all that apply

    9. Select every line in Evidence 4 that is an indicator of compromise.

    Select every line in Evidence 4 that is an indicator of compromise.
    Show answer

    Answer: A, B, D. 198.51.100.0/24 is a known malicious range, the burst of failed logins is a password attack, and the server the contractor account just logged in to is now calling a known malicious address. The 02:03 page load is normal. CED 3.5.E.7

  10. Detect Choose one

    10. The clinic wants better detection on its network, which carries sensitive patient data. Which detection method fits best?

    The clinic wants better detection on its network, which carries sensitive patient data. Which detection method fits best?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Networks with more sensitive or critical data or services will likely consider a hybrid approach, which combines signature- and anomaly-based detection but costs more and generates more alerts. CED 3.5.C.3

Write it up: cite the log line

On the free-response question, name the attack and quote the line that proves it; a general "the logs show it" is unlikely to earn the point. For each finding, pick the exact line, write your mitigation, then compare with the model answer. About 10 minutes, not part of the score above.

  1. Write-up E4 Pick one line, then write

    1. The contractor account was taken over. Pick the one line in Evidence 4 that shows the adversary got in, then write one mitigation.

    Pick the line from Evidence 4 that proves it
    Show the model answer

    The line: 02:10 192.0.2.77 -> 10.0.1.30:3389 ALLOW rule 3 login SUCCESS: contractor

    The 02:10 line records a successful login for the contractor account from 192.0.2.77, the same address that failed 238 times at 02:08. The 02:08 line shows the attack; only the 02:10 line proves it worked.

    Model mitigation: Limit rule 3 so remote desktop (port 3389) is allowed only from the contractor’s known address, and require multifactor authentication (MFA) for the contractor account.

    Mark yourself. Your write-up earns the points if it:

    • Quotes the 02:10 line (or its time and "login SUCCESS: contractor"), not "the log shows it".
    • Gives a mitigation aimed at this attack: restrict rule 3’s source, require MFA, or lock the account after repeated failed logins.

    CED 3.5.E.7, 3.4.D.2

  2. Write-up E4 Pick one line, then write

    2. After the takeover, the contractor’s server started talking to the adversary. Pick the line that shows the contractor’s server (10.0.1.30) connecting out to a known malicious address, then write one mitigation.

    Pick the line from Evidence 4 that proves it
    Show the model answer

    The line: 02:14 10.0.1.30 -> 203.0.113.66:443 ALLOW out outbound connection

    At 02:14 the server 10.0.1.30 opened an outbound connection to 203.0.113.66, which is in 203.0.113.0/24, on the clinic’s list of known malicious addresses. A connection to a known malicious IP address is a network-based indicator of compromise.

    Model mitigation: Add an outbound rule that denies all traffic to 203.0.113.0/24, and disconnect 10.0.1.30 from the network until it has been checked.

    Mark yourself. Your write-up earns the points if it:

    • Quotes the 02:14 line and names 203.0.113.66 as a known malicious address.
    • Gives a mitigation aimed at this connection: block outbound traffic to that range, or isolate the server.

    CED 3.5.E.7

  3. Write-up E3 Pick one line, then write

    3. Pick the line in Evidence 3 that shows MAC flooding, then write one mitigation.

    Pick the line from Evidence 3 that proves it
    Show the model answer

    The line: Fa0/7 (waiting room wall port) 8,189 dynamic addresses

    Port Fa0/7, the waiting room wall port, has 8,189 dynamic addresses while every other port has one. Thousands of MAC addresses on a single port, filling the table, is the sign of MAC flooding. The total line shows the table filling, but only the Fa0/7 line shows where the flood comes from.

    Model mitigation: Enable port security on Fa0/7 with a maximum of one address, and disable the wall port while it is not needed.

    Mark yourself. Your write-up earns the points if it:

    • Quotes the Fa0/7 line and its 8,189 addresses.
    • Names port security on that port (or disabling the port) as the mitigation.

    CED 3.5.E.4, 3.3.B.4

Was this page helpful?

No names are ever shown, and every public comment is checked by us first. Please do not include personal details. To get a reply, email [email protected].

Course mapYou are here: Unit 3
Top

Enlarged view of the selected figure